PROJECTS FEEDBACK
Any participant in the INSPIRELI AWARDS competition can ask a member of the international jury for feedback on his/her competition project. Jurors are assigned across continents at a ratio of one juror per student. The resulting gallery is a unique architecture textbook, created free of charge by those who wish to participate in our project and contribute their work to the education of the up and coming generation. We are honored that you are sharing your designs and experiences here.
393 Results
Shopping Mall projects feedbacks
I am very glad to see that the classification of senses and the activity area can be clearly analyzed and combined, which is undoubtedly a very beneficial thing for the visually impaired. The sensory understanding shown in the picture is also in place, as well as a reasonable understanding of relevant laws and regulations. What I want to say is that as a project with very practical needs, We may need to pay more attention to the understanding of some small scenes. For example, some scenes…
QingYang Jia
advisor
There is little sense of intrusion into the building, and it is better to have frames for intrusion. The legibility of the plan is low
Amir Kolivand
advisor
There is little sense of intrusion into the building, and it is better to have frames for intrusion.
Amir Kolivand
advisor
Among several projects under - Schindler's Ark Saving Competition - that I reviewed I think your project closely follows the theme and overall context of the region. I like your process diagram and how you intend to maintain the overall look and appeal but the project could have been even more interesting if you had incorporated the actualities more strongly. History informs us that the place was used as a factory first for textile and later for enamelware; I strongly believe that traits of…
Himanshu Sanghani
advisor
I appreciate the fact that you have tried to design by sensitising yourself to understand social spaces and energy efficiency. However, these are investigated by you in a restrictive way, you could have gone beyond the basic strategies and principles of tall towers. When you are incorporating above concepts in your design then building services play an important role, I did not see any service area other than toilet, lifts and staircases on the floor. What services are required for electricity,…
Himanshu Sanghani
advisor
I really appreciate the concept and the starting point of this project, and how the ideas are translated into space, materials and experience. Great design and great details, with intriguing interior renderings, I found this as a very successful practice.
Ziyang Xu
advisor
PROJECT: REDEVELOPMENT OF SYLHET OLD CENTRAL JAIL AREA (An opportunity to create an urban activity area for Sylhet city) STUDENT: RIDAY SAHA INSTITUTION: Bangladesh University, Department of Architecture, Dhaka COUNTRY: Bangladesh SEMIFINAL JUROR: Wandile Sibandze 1. STRENGTHS: Interpreting the memory of a place in terms of heritage architecture and the importance of its preservation (specific understanding of the unique environment) convincingly. The subject matter is well understood and…
Wandile Sibandze
advisor
In my opinion, this project remains an interesting concept that, following an exhaustive study, could become an inspiring model for similar initiatives on a global scale. However, I am skeptical about the risks associated with public safety, particularly regarding public access during the construction phase, which could pose significant safety concerns. Even with precautions in place, there is a considerable risk that the process of dismantling and dune creation could disrupt the surrounding…
Josefina MONTE-NGUBA SIALE
advisor
A well-thought-out change of use project. I particularly appreciated the created atmospheres, the careful lighting, and the volumes with generous heights. However, it would have been useful to have a site survey plan to allow for a comparison between the existing conditions and the proposed modifications, or to better understand the adaptation of the spaces.
Josefina MONTE-NGUBA SIALE
advisor
Copyright © 2024 INSPIRELI | All rights reserved. Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and use of cookies.
